Peer Review Process
Scientific Exploration: Journal of Indonesian Academic Research accepts manuscripts in English or Bahasa Indonesia and uses single-blind peer review: reviewers know the identity of the authors, while the identity of the reviewers is not disclosed to the authors. The process follows the COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers.
Stages
- Submission – the corresponding author submits the manuscript through the journal's online system (OJS). All correspondence takes place in the system.
- Initial screening (within 7 days) – the editors check the manuscript for fit with the Focus and Scope, compliance with the Author Guidelines, and required statements. Manuscripts that do not meet these criteria are rejected or returned to the authors without external review.
- Similarity check – every manuscript is checked with Turnitin before review (see Screening for Plagiarism). Manuscripts above the threshold are returned or rejected.
- Peer review – the editor assigns at least two independent reviewers with expertise in the manuscript's subject. Reviewers return their evaluation within 14 days; an extension may be requested.
- Editorial decision – based on the reviewers' reports, the handling editor recommends, and the Editor-in-Chief decides, to accept, request minor revision, request major revision, or reject the manuscript. When reviewers disagree, the editor may invite an additional reviewer.
- Revision – authors return a revised manuscript with a point-by-point response within 14 days (minor revision) or 30 days (major revision). Revisions are checked by the editor and, for major revisions, returned to the reviewers.
- Final decision and production – accepted manuscripts proceed to copyediting, layout, and proofreading by the authors before publication.
Review criteria. Reviewers assess:
- originality and contribution to knowledge, including a clear research gap;
- relevance to the journal's scope;
- soundness of the methods and adequacy of the data;
- depth of analysis and comparison with relevant, recent literature;
- whether the conclusions answer the objectives and are supported by the results;
- quality of the title, abstract, figures, tables, and references;
- research ethics, including ethical approval where human participants or animals are involved.
Reviewers are asked to give substantive comments on the content, not only on language or layout.
Reviewer qualifications. Reviewers hold at least a master's degree (preferably a doctorate) in a relevant field and have published, as first or corresponding author, in an accredited national journal or an international journal within the past three years.
Confidentiality and conflicts of interest. Manuscripts are confidential. Reviewers must not share them or upload them to any AI tool (see AI Policy), and must decline an assignment when they have a conflict of interest (see Conflict of Interest).
Final authority. The Editor-in-Chief has the final authority on publication. Decisions are based only on academic merit.


