Post-publication Discussion

Scientific Exploration: Journal of Indonesian Academic Research welcomes scholarly discussion of articles after publication, because it helps correct the scientific record and improve research.

How to comment. Readers may submit a comment on a published article by e-mail to [email protected], with the subject line "Post-publication comment" followed by the article title. A comment should:

  • refer to a specific article published in the journal, citing its DOI;
  • address the scientific content (methods, data, analysis, or conclusions), not the authors personally;
  • be no longer than 1,000 words and include supporting references where relevant;
  • include the commenter's full name, affiliation, and any conflict of interest.

Handling. The editors assess each comment for relevance and courtesy. Suitable comments are sent to the authors of the original article, who are invited to reply within 30 days. The comment and the authors' reply may be published together as Correspondence or a Letter to the Editor, linked to the original article. Comments that are abusive, defamatory, or outside the article's scope will not be published.

Outcomes. If a comment reveals an error or a possible case of misconduct, the editors will proceed under the journal's Correction and Retraction policy or its policy on Allegations of Research Misconduct.