Allegations of Research Misconduct

Scientific Exploration: Journal of Indonesian Academic Research takes all allegations of research and publication misconduct seriously and handles them in line with the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) flowcharts and guidelines.

What counts as misconduct. Research misconduct includes, but is not limited to:

  • Fabrication – making up data or results;
  • Falsification – manipulating data, images, or research processes;
  • Plagiarism – using another person's work or ideas, or one's own previously published work, without proper acknowledgement;
  • Improper authorship – gift, guest, or ghost authorship, or omitting a person who contributed;
  • Undisclosed conflict of interest that may have influenced the work;
  • Duplicate or multiple submission – submitting the same work to more than one journal, or publishing it more than once;
  • Citation or peer-review manipulation, including fake reviewer identities;
  • Ethical violations in research involving humans or animals, including lack of ethical approval.

How to report. Anyone (readers, reviewers, authors, or institutions) may report a concern to the Editor-in-Chief at [email protected]. Reports should identify the article and describe the concern with supporting evidence. Anonymous reports are considered if they contain sufficient specific evidence.

Procedure. The journal handles every allegation through the following documented steps:

  1. Preliminary assessment – the Editor-in-Chief checks whether the allegation is within the journal's remit and supported by initial evidence.
  2. Clarification – the authors are informed of the concern and asked to respond in writing within 30 days.
  3. Investigation – if the response is unsatisfactory, the editors investigate, may consult independent experts, and may contact the authors' institution or funder.
  4. Decision – the Editor-in-Chief decides the outcome based on the evidence.
  5. Corrective action – depending on the outcome, the journal may reject the manuscript, publish a correction or expression of concern, retract the article (see Correction and Retraction), inform the authors' institution, and/or bar the authors from submitting for a defined period.

All steps are recorded and kept confidential while the case is ongoing. The journal aims to act promptly and will not delete published articles to resolve an allegation.