Publication Ethics

Scientific Exploration: Journal of Indonesian Academic Research follows the Core Practices of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). This page sets out what the journal expects from authors, editors, reviewers, and the journal management. The related policies listed at the end of the page give the details.

Authors

  1. Original work. A manuscript must be the authors' own original work. Text, data, figures, or ideas taken from other sources, including the authors' own earlier publications, must be cited. Plagiarism in any form leads to rejection or, after publication, retraction (see Screening for Plagiarism).
  2. Accurate reporting. Authors must report their methods and results honestly and in enough detail for others to check them. Fabricating or falsifying data is serious misconduct.
  3. Data access and retention. Authors should keep the raw data behind their findings and make them available to the editors on request (see Data Availability and Ethics).
  4. No duplicate submission. A manuscript submitted to the journal must not have been published or be under review elsewhere. A manuscript found to be submitted to another journal at the same time is rejected.
  5. Authorship. Everyone listed as an author must meet the journal's authorship criteria, and everyone who meets them must be listed (see Authorship Criteria). The corresponding author handles all correspondence with the journal on behalf of the co-authors and confirms that all of them have approved the submitted version.
  6. Research ethics. Research involving human participants, including students and school children, or animals must have ethical approval or the appropriate institutional permission, and informed consent from participants or their parents or guardians. The manuscript must state how this was obtained.
  7. Use of AI tools. Authors must disclose any use of generative AI tools in preparing the manuscript and remain fully responsible for its content (see AI Policy).
  8. Funding and conflicts of interest. Authors must disclose all sources of funding and any financial or personal relationship that could be seen to influence the work (see Conflict of Interest).
  9. Errors in published work. Authors who find a significant error in their published article must inform the editor promptly and cooperate in publishing a correction or retraction (see Correction and Retraction).

Editors

  1. Fair decisions. Editors accept or reject a manuscript only on the basis of its originality, quality, relevance to the journal's scope, and the reviewers' reports, regardless of the authors' ethnicity, religion, race, gender, nationality, institution, or political views.
  2. Peer review. Editors make sure that every manuscript considered for publication is reviewed by at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise, and that decisions are made without undue delay (see Peer Review Process).
  3. Confidentiality. Editors do not disclose information about a submitted manuscript to anyone other than the authors, reviewers, and editorial staff involved in handling it.
  4. Conflicts of interest. Editors do not handle manuscripts in which they have a conflict of interest, including their own submissions, which are assigned to another editor. Editors do not use unpublished material from a submitted manuscript in their own research without the authors' written consent.
  5. Clear information. Editors keep the Author Guidelines, journal policies, and journal information accurate, current, and openly accessible.
  6. Handling misconduct. Editors respond to suspected misconduct in submitted or published work by following COPE guidance (see Allegations of Research Misconduct).

Reviewers

  1. Contribution to decisions. Reviewers help the editors reach a decision and help the authors improve their manuscripts.
  2. Timeliness. A reviewer who feels unqualified to review a manuscript, or who cannot complete the review within 14 days, should tell the editor promptly.
  3. Confidentiality. Manuscripts under review are confidential. Reviewers must not share them, use their content in their own work, or upload them to generative AI tools.
  4. Objectivity. Reviews should be objective and constructive, with clearly supported comments. Personal criticism of the authors is not appropriate.
  5. Acknowledgement of sources. Reviewers should point out relevant published work that the authors have not cited and tell the editor about any substantial similarity between the manuscript and other published work.
  6. Conflicts of interest. Reviewers must decline to review a manuscript in which they have a competing interest arising from a collaborative, competitive, financial, or personal relationship with the authors.

Journal management

  1. Editorial independence. The publisher and the journal management do not interfere in editorial decisions.
  2. Transparency. The journal publishes its policies, fees, ownership, and management openly (see Article Processing Charge and Ownership and Management).
  3. Copyright and archiving. Articles are published under the CC BY-SA 4.0 licence (from Vol. 4, 2026; articles in Vol. 1–3 remain under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0), and the journal makes sure that published articles are preserved over the long term (see Copyright Notice and Archiving).
  4. Conflicts of interest. Members of the journal management declare any interest that could affect the running of the journal.

Peer Review Process · Authorship Criteria · Conflict of Interest · Screening for Plagiarism · AI Policy · Data Availability and Ethics · Allegations of Research Misconduct · Correction and Retraction · Post-publication Discussion