Screening for Plagiarism

Every manuscript submitted to Scientific Exploration: Journal of Indonesian Academic Research is checked for similarity with Turnitin before peer review, and again before publication if it was substantially revised.

Thresholds. The similarity report is generated excluding the reference list and properly quoted text. A manuscript normally proceeds to review when:

  • the overall similarity index is no more than 20%, and
  • the similarity with any single source is no more than 3%.

A similarity percentage is only an indicator. The editor always reads the report to judge whether the overlap is acceptable (for example, standard method descriptions) or indicates plagiarism.

Classification and action

Finding Example Action
Minor Short passages copied without quotation marks but with citation Returned to the authors for revision
Moderate Paragraphs taken from other sources with little rewording, or reuse of the authors' own published text without citation Rejected, or returned for major revision at the editor's discretion
Severe Large blocks or most of the manuscript copied; data, figures, or ideas taken without acknowledgement; duplicate publication Rejected and handled under the policy on Allegations of Research Misconduct

Self-plagiarism. Reusing one's own published text, data, or figures without citing the original source counts as plagiarism. Submitting the same manuscript to more than one journal is not allowed.

After publication. If plagiarism is found in a published article, the journal follows its Correction and Retraction policy. Retracted articles remain online, marked "RETRACTED".

Records. Similarity reports are kept in the journal's management system and may be shared with the authors.